MILWAUKEE – On behalf of the Wisconsin Council of Churches, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Wisconsin today filed a friend-of-the court brief in support of the City of Milwaukee’s ordinance banning ICE agents from wearing masks to hide their identities.
In the wake of unprecedented federal immigration enforcement in Chicago and Minneapolis, the Milwaukee Common Council sought to protect Milwaukee residents against ambushes by armed, masked, and unidentified law enforcement agents.
To that end, the Common Council passed an ordinance prohibiting all law enforcement from wearing face coverings while interacting with the public in the performance of their duties. The ordinance also requires that all law enforcement officers either display on their uniforms the name of their agency and the officer’s last name, badge number, or identification number or verbally provide this information upon request. The US Department of Justice sued the City to prevent the ban from being enforced.
The brief argues that allowing the federal government to continue deploying masked, unidentifiable, heavily-armed officers to Milwaukee would inflict concrete harm on city residents by permitting federal immigration enforcement to proceed under conditions of anonymity, impunity and escalating violence.
There are numerous instances in Minneapolis, Chicago and elsewhere of ICE agents descending on community members, often in unmarked vehicles, refusing to share any identifying information about themselves. These ambushes – indistinguishable from kidnappings – escalate the risk of danger to those encountering the agents, bystanders, and law enforcement alike.
The brief also points out that masked and unidentifiable law enforcement raids eviscerate public trust and enable opportunities for impersonators. Many of these immigration operations have made people afraid to leave their homes, go to work, attend religious gatherings, and make their medical appointments. People are also less likely to come forward and alert authorities when they witness crime. Because law enforcement officials are wearing masks to conceal themselves, it has also enabled individuals who have assaulted and kidnapped others to falsely pose as ICE agents. The FBI reported multiple instances of impersonation in 2025.
The brief also notes that the anonymity of officers makes accountability for misconduct much harder. There are hundreds of reports of constitutional violations by federal agents for which individuals have extreme difficulty seeking relief given the anonymity of the law enforcement personnel. Without knowing officers’ names, badge numbers, or agency affiliation, or remembering their face, victims cannot identify responsible parties or pursue legal remedies when their rights have been violated.
“ICE agents and other law enforcement routinely break the law and have violently harassed, assaulted, abused and even killed multiple people while conducting reckless immigration operations across the country,” said ACLU of Wisconsin Staff Attorney Hannah Schwarz. “Agents have been able to get away with unlawful conduct in part because their use of masks makes them nearly impossible to identify. We cannot have members of law enforcement, who have a duty to serve the public, hiding behind masks, refusing to identify themselves, and operating in secret. No one is above the law – especially not those responsible for enforcing it. This ordinance will bring a measure of transparency and public accountability to all members of law enforcement operating in Milwaukee.”
The press release and brief are available online here: https://www.aclu-wi.org/press-releases/aclu-of-wisconsin-files-brief-supporting-milwaukee-ban-on-ice-masks-amid-doj-challenge/