Yesterday, I stood with Corey Ruiz’s family at their news conference at The Center for Black Excellence and Culture, after they received news they did not deserve. I also stood with them in July at their first news conference at the State Capitol, days after Corey was killed.

I know this family. Corey’s daughter, Kah’Liyah Aliomar, attended One City Schools for several years, and her mother, Marjorie, was an active member of our parent council. They did not deserve this. Corey did not deserve this. His family did not deserve this.

I know what some will say: Mr. Ruiz had a knife, and an officer felt threatened. Those facts matter. That is exactly why they belonged before a jury. Today, according to the family’s attorney Ben Crump, District Attorney Ismael Ozanne told the family there were no signs the officer had been cut or stabbed. Four officers were on the scene. Three had wrestled Corey to the ground. One used a Taser that knocked him to the ground and clearly incapacitated him. Then the shots were fired that killed him. Since when is an officer allowed to shoot someone three times, and once in the head, when they are subdued and lying on the ground, with no firearm pointed at them?

In my view, the officer should have been charged with reckless homicide.

Under Wisconsin law, reckless homicide does not mean the officer meant to kill. It means a person caused a death by creating an unreasonable and substantial risk of death or great bodily harm, while being aware of that risk. That is second-degree reckless homicide. First-degree reckless homicide adds one more element: circumstances that show utter disregard for human life. In this case, prosecutors would have had to prove that firing three shots at a man already on the ground, after a Taser had been used and with other officers beside him, created a risk that was unreasonable and that the officer knew he was taking. The officer would have had every right to argue that he acted in self-defense. A jury would have decided.

That said, some will argue that a prosecutor should never bring a case he doubts he can win. I respect that standard. However, when the facts are this contested, with no body camera footage and only bystander video, that is exactly when twelve members of our community should weigh the evidence and decide. That is what juries are for. A trial would not have guaranteed any outcome, but it would have guaranteed that the evidence was heard in the open, and that the community, not one office, decided. Instead, District Attorney Ozanne made that decision for all of us.

Unfortunately, that choice will deepen distrust in his office and in law enforcement, and at a time when our city can least afford it. It also denies everyone, including the officer and the Madison Police Department, the public answer a trial would have given.

Many residents heard a stinging message yesterday: when an officer takes a life, it is nearly impossible to have that act examined before a jury. Whatever the intent, that is what people heard. Our city will struggle with this decision for years, and that distrust will not be easy to overcome.

For the record, I support law enforcement. I served in the United States Navy. Accountability is not an attack on the police. Instead, it is how good officers earn and keep the public’s trust. I do not support injustice, and I believe an injustice happened today. Ismael Ozanne and I have been friends since childhood, and I love his family. However, I believe my friend made the wrong decision.

So the question now is, what do we do next? How do we make sure every resident, in every neighborhood, feels safe with the people sworn to protect them? The mayor must play a central role in building that trust, alongside Madison’s Chief of Police and the officers’ union.

Yesterday, our mayor missed that opportunity again. Leadership means showing up when it is hard, not only when it is easy. When an officer is harmed, the mayor should be there. When a resident is killed by police in such a manner, the mayor should be there to comfort that family, too. That is the standard I will hold myself to.

To Kah’Liyah, her mother Marjorie, and everyone who loved Corey: you are not alone. Madison is with you. And to the officers of the Madison Police Department: we must work together to rebuild the trust our city needs, and our police officers need.