DPI’s budget request would end automatic funding increases for voucher schools while phasing out a scholarship program for special needs students to attend the choice program.

One choice advocate said the proposed changes amount to a long-term effort to phase out the program.

“It might take more than a couple of years, but you would see schools that would have to remove themselves from the program and try to get more private pay students to account for that difference,” said Ashley Czaja, president of School Choice Wisconsin.

But DPI spokesperson Chris Bucher countered the agency’s proposed changes for choice schools seek to impose clear expectations of how public dollars are used and how students are served.

The DPI budget released Friday includes language stating the department is proposing other statutory changes “aimed at creating greater accountability for the private school choice program” that would be included in a separate document. Those details weren’t yet available today, the agency said.

“It is pretty simple: public money requires public accountability,” Bucher said.

The agency’s budget request calls for putting $2.75 billion in new general purpose revenue into a revamped school funding formula. The document also calls for taking $2.55 billion that’s slated over the next two years for the school levy credit and instead pumping that into the proposed formula, as well. In all, it would amount to a nearly $5.4 billion increase in state aid to schools.

But the agency said Friday the combination of new aid and the proposed increase in per pupil spending would keep property taxes flat over the next two years.

The agency’s Friday release providing an overview of the budget proposal didn’t highlight any of the proposed changes to the voucher programs in Milwaukee, Racine and statewide.

Those changes include:

  • Ending current law that increases voucher payments anytime the per pupil spending limit for public schools is increased.
  • Ending the two-tiered payment structure that now provides a voucher of $13,799 for students in high school and $11,305 for those in K-8. Instead, it would be a flat payment of $12,552 regardless of grade level.
  • Beginning to phase out the scholarship for special needs students to attend choice schools starting in fiscal year 2028-29 by allowing new pupils to enroll after the 2027-28 school year. 

The DPI budget also would make a series of changes to charter schools, most notably giving the agency oversight of approving them. 

That power is now granted to entities outside of DPI, including universities, the Office of Educational Opportunity within the Universities of Wisconsin, technical colleges, the city of Milwaukee and the Waukesha County executive.

Jim Bender, executive director of Wisconsin Independent Charter School Advocates, also noted the DPI budget proposes additional funding for economically disadvantaged students and English learners. 

Rather than counting them as a single student in the funding formula, there would be an additional 0.2 for poor students and 0.2 for English learners. That would mean a student who is both economically disadvantaged and an English learner would count as a 1.4 full-time equivalent student in the funding formula. 

It wouldn’t apply to students in choice or charter schools.  

“If we’re going to weight students, we should weight all the students,” Bender said.

State Superintendent Jill Underly told WisPolitics in a phone interview that DPI’s budget proposal seeks to fix a school funding formula that “used to work” while restoring a constitutional promise to fund education.

Underly acknowledged that it’s a “large request,” but she contends it’s “making up” for different shortfalls over the years. 

“The formula used to work. It’s just weathered 30-plus years of different tweaks and changes and different legislatures taking money out of it, which has rendered it rather broken. And so what this does is it makes that formula whole again,” Underly said.

Underly, who was unavailable for comment Friday when the proposal was released, said the budget request would put money that was “supposed to be” in the formula back into the equation and index it to inflation to ideally put operational funding referendums “out of business.”

Read more in the MON PM Update.