MADISON – Senator Eric Wimberger (R-Gillett) and Representative Robert Wittke (R-Caledonia) issued the following statement after the Legislative Audit Bureau released Audit Report 26-18, the findings from an audit investigation into changes within the annual Wisconsin school district performance report cards issued by the Department of Public Instruction (DPI):
Senator Wimberger stated, “DPI circumvented statutes, lowered cut scores so that otherwise failing schools appear to be on track, refused to maintain records or make reports of their actions, and cooked the books monitoring achievement gaps. State Superintendent Underly and DPI hid from open meetings law requirements by claiming it was a meeting with vendors, spending approximately $375,000 on a 4-day resort conference with 32 hand-picked superintendents to deceptively overhaul school report cards. Schools are ‘meeting standards’ even when students fail. In short, DPI unilaterally turned school report cards into an untrustworthy sham.”
The investigation found DPI does not consistently follow state law by failing to disclose certain legally required information to the public in its annual school and school district accountability report cards. These include a measure of how DPI is closing gaps in student achievement in reading and math based on students’ English proficiency, disability, income level, race, and ethnicity. Rather, DPI has opted to measure “target group outcomes” for a specific group of selected students instead following the statutorily required procedure.
State auditors also found that DPI inconsistently followed the state’s open meetings laws as it considered making serious changes to its report card process. DPI held two open, publicly noticed meetings to solicit feedback from the public on changes to performance thresholds in the report cards. However, DPI did not publicly notice its four-day workshop at a resort in the Wisconsin Dells to work with outside contractors and make the eventual changes to the report card process.
Auditors also found that DPI employed a unique strategy to potentially falsely boost its own student achievement scores. Under DPI policy, the Department selectively chose to report some school districts’ higher scores from the 2022-23 year instead of their lower scores in 2023-24 year to ensure there was not a decrease in student achievement scores heading into the 2024-25 school year.
Representative Wittke said, “Accountability is not optional. The Department of Public Instruction must demonstrate that it is putting Wisconsin students, families, and schools ahead of politics and bureaucracy. The Legislative Audit Bureau has a responsibility to provide independent, objective oversight of how taxpayer dollars are spent and how state agencies perform their duties. That responsibility should never be dismissed as politics simply because the findings are uncomfortable. Our children deserve an education system that puts student achievement first. Wisconsin taxpayers deserve transparency and accountability, not excuses.”
As chairs of the Audit Committee, Senator Wimberger and Representative Wittke led the Committee to authorize the audit of DPI’s school district accountability report card process in February 2025.
In February 2026, a report found that DPI spent $368,885 on a four-day workshop at a Wisconsin Dells resort to plan changes to the proficiency standards on Wisconsin’s Forward Exam, a major component of the annual report cards. Further reporting revealed this retreat was part of an $8 million effort to lower standards of the Forward Exam scoring process in an attempt to paper over failures in Wisconsin schools under Superintendent Underly.
Recent testing results published by DPI show that nearly half of Wisconsin’s students are not reading or doing math at their grade level, despite DPI claiming this week in its most recent report cards that nearly 95% of schools receiving a report card were meeting, exceeding, or significantly exceeding the Department’s expectations.